A callback rule only protects trust money if it names who makes the call, which number they use and who approves the payment. A payment email can arrive in the right matter thread, from a familiar name, and still carry false bank details, so the rule has to work when the email looks perfect.
The Australian Cyber Security Centre's business email compromise guidance recommends a consistent process for checking payment requests and account changes, and the Law Society of NSW and Lawcover's client guidance (PDF) says to call a known contact on a number already held, not the one in a suspicious email. Most firms agree. Where it fails is when nobody has decided the details in advance.
Four decisions for a partners' meeting
A rule with job titles in it gets interpreted under pressure. A rule with names in it gets followed.
- The person who checks is not the person who received the email. A second person isn't caught up in the thread, and it takes the pressure off the lawyer being chased by the client or the other side. Anyone with a doubt tells that person in person or by phone, because the mailbox may be the thing that's been broken into.
- The number comes from the file, never from the email. For your own client, that's the number recorded when the matter was opened. For the other side's solicitor, the agent or a financier, it's a number the firm got somewhere other than email, such as one on a letter received by post, or one the firm has used safely on an earlier matter. On a new matter with neither, confirm the number through a source other than email before any money moves, and note on the file where it came from. Never use the number in an email signature or a web search result: a fake page can carry a fake number.
- A named partner approves the payment, with a named backup. If the approver is at court or away, staff know exactly who decides. Nobody should have to choose between the check and the deadline on their own.
- The check is written on the matter file. Who called, on what number, at what time, and what the other person confirmed. If a payment is ever questioned, that note is what the firm will rely on.
The rule covers first-time payment details too: a new account carries the same risk as a changed one, with nothing to compare it against.
Attach it to the trust transfer you already authorise
Your trust account procedure already has someone who authorises transfers out of trust. That's where the callback belongs. The authoriser doesn't approve a payment to new or changed details until the callback note is on the matter file, and if the note isn't there, the transfer waits.
The approver then sees, rather than assumes, that someone called.
Settlement day is when the rule gets tested
A deadline shouldn't turn an unverified change into an approved one. The ACSC has warned about false bank details inserted into property settlement payments.
So agree, in a calm meeting, what happens when a changed instruction can't be verified in time: the details don't go into the PEXA workspace or the bank transfer, even if settlement has to move. A junior lawyer who delays a settlement because the callback failed should know the partners will back them. If that isn't settled in advance, the deadline will make the decision instead.
The sentence for money coming in
The same rule protects money your clients pay you. Put the same words in the engagement letter and the first email. Most banks now check the name a payer enters against the account and report a match, a close match or no match (Confirmation of Payee), so give clients the exact name. For example:
> We will never tell you about a change to our bank details by email. Our account name is [your exact trust account name]. If your bank says the name doesn't match ours, or an email says our details have changed, don't pay. Call us first on the number in this letter.
Then check your standard payment emails say the same. If one treats an email reply as confirmation, the client has to choose which instruction to trust. How the attack itself runs, in both directions, is in how email fraud steals a settlement payment.
If money may already have moved
If the firm made the payment, call the firm's bank immediately; if the client paid, tell them to call their own bank straight away. The ACSC's recovery guidance covers the steps that follow. Tell the firm's professional indemnity insurer and any cyber insurer promptly. If trust money is involved, the Law Society of NSW says irregularities and suspected irregularities, including fraud and cyber-crime affecting trust money, must be reported to the Law Society as soon as practicable, whatever the amount.
The part that stays with your partners
CRYPTON can help your firm write down an agreed callback check for changed payment details, so everyone works from the same page. The rule itself, and backing the person who delays a payment to follow it, is something only your partners can set and enforce. Talk to CRYPTON about putting your callback rule in writing, or call (02) 9000 1824.